intentBlog intent is the emerging asian consciousness giving birth to a global mind shift

Spoofing Kaavya

Kavita Chhibber - August 17, 2006

For a Change

A hilarious piece written by Melvin Durai, that I happened to read.
Enjoy!


“Don’t Call me Plagiarist"
Melvin Durai

Let me make one thing clear: I am not a plagiarist. I have never plagiarized anything, though I’m willing to admit that the title of my new book “How Gopal Mehta Got Dissed, Got Riled, and Got a Knife” is somewhat similar to the title of another young-adult novel that was recently withdrawn from bookstores. I’m also willing to admit that certain passages in my book are somewhat similar to the passages in 13 other books, seven magazine pieces, and four John Kerry speeches.

But let me reiterate: I am not a plagiarist. I am quite capable of originality. In fact, as various media outlets have reported, the dedication to my book is completely original. I wrote it myself, with a little input from Amalgam Entertainment. The input was so minimal, I applied for and was granted full copyright of the dedication page.
It should also be noted that at least 11 percent, perhaps as much as 12 percent, of my novel is fully original. I can say this with almost 60% certainty. This portion has never been printed before and has never appeared anywhere else, aside from the obscure website where I found it.

While the various other parts of my novel are not original, it’s clear to my supporters, as stated in various blogs, that the combination or “amalgam” is. No one else has ever published a novel with passages copied from the same books, magazines and speeches, arranged brilliantly to create first-rate young-adult literature.

Though I take some pride in this originality, I must admit that it was wholly unintentional. I did not set out to borrow from anyone else’s work. It happened quite accidentally, as the following examples will show.

Chapter 1: Several paragraphs in the opening chapter are similar to paragraphs in Salman Rushdie’s “Midnight’s Children.” It has been almost 20 years since I read Rushdie’s novel, but I’ve been cursed with a photographic memory. These paragraphs had been stored somewhere in my head and, when they came out, I thought they were my own. I felt inspired and thrilled, believing I was a brilliant writer who would win a Booker Prize and whose fourth wife would be a gorgeous model.

Chapter 2: This chapter consists mainly of a short story called “Nobody’s Business.” I thought it would be perfectly acceptable to put it in my book, since one of my friends had emailed it to me. His subject line – “Here’s a good story for you” – led me to believe that he was passing all rights to me. I have since learned that the story was written by Pulitzer Prize-winning author Jhumpa Lahiri. In future editions of my book, I will acknowledge her contribution. I am also prepared to share royalties with her, as long as she agrees to accompany me on a promotional tour for our book. (Sharing a hotel room is optional.)

Chapter 3: This chapter consists of passages from Arundhati Roy’s “The God of Small Things” and Suketu Mehta’s “Maximum City.” During the research for my novel, I had taken lengthy notes from these books. When writing my novel, I consulted the notes and thought they were my own words. They sounded like something I would have written. Indeed, I did write them, but not as the original writer. To acknowledge their contributions, I have sent the authors autographed copies of my (and Jhumpa’s) book. I will also name my next child “Suketu.”

Chapter 4: This chapter borrows heavily from Ernest Hemingway and Flannery O’Connor stories. Since they had both passed away in the last century, it was my honest belief that their work had become public domain. I had always wanted to write like them and felt grateful that I was finally able to do so.

Chapter 5: This chapter contains entire pages from Kaavya Viswanathan’s young-adult novel that was recently withdrawn from bookstores. I blame this on my research assistant, who provided me with “research material” from a number of novels. In copying from Viswanathan’s novel, my assistant had inadvertently copied from several novels that Viswanathan had inadvertently copied from. Neither of us is a plagiarist, not me especially.

Chapter 6: This chapter was rewritten by someone at my book packaging company, Amalgam Entertainment, a man who apparently used to write speeches for John Kerry. I did not realize this until my friends complimented me on my character’s declaration when he joins an Indian gang in New York City: “I’m Gopal Mehta, and I’m reporting for duty.”

Digg this entryDigg this entry  Add to Del.icio.usAdd to Del.icio.us  Share on FacebookShare on Facebook  Subscribe to this AuthorSubscribe

Posted by Kavita Chhibber at August 17, 2006 05:51 AM

Comments

Hi Kavita,

Imitation is said to be the best form of flattery. By plagiarizing someone’s work, we pay the ultimate compliment to their artistic caliber!

I think we all plagiarize to some extent. The art of plagiarism lies in doing it such a subtle manner that even You don’t get a wind of it! In every art form, the artist does have the propensity to unconsciously imbibe the style and manner of some great artist they admire. There’s nothing wrong with it, as long as you do not regurgitate the content in the exact same manner, the tragic mistake that Kaavya made! Borrow the ideas, the style by all means. But have enough intellectual honesty not to be a copycat.

In Bollywood, we saw Shah Rukh Khan unabashedly dittoing Amitabh Bachchan’s acting style in the first one or two of his movies. But gradually he realized that to become an actor in his own right, he had to develop a style of his own. Which he did. And Today he is the King Khan! If he hadn’t, he would, like Kaavya Vishwanathan, have got rich, got caught, and got ruined!!

Sanjeev

Dear Kavita,
One of my favorite authors, Jorge Luis Borges, said once that there are only a few stories in the world. (I don't remember the exact quote.) If that's true, humanity and writers repeat these few stories adding their unique soul qualities. Each story is then enriched.
Love,
Donatella

"Every writer "creates" his own precursors. His work modifies our conception of the past, as it will modify the future."
Jorge Luis Borges

There is only "One Being" Kavita, you have written everything ever written. One cannot plagiarize One's self, from any of it's points of view.

That some other wrote, something, is simply an appearance.

One has written everything they have ever read.

Of course most can't see beyond the appearances so we have things like copyright it helps maintain the Illusion.

Guys I have to run but please don't take this seriously. Melvin Durai is a well known humorist, satirist and this post is just for laughs, not to beat the poor kid to death again..so please take it in that spirit.
Sanjeev, amitabh bachchan copied dilip kumar and does to this day.. when I asked him how dilip kumar felt at being talked back in the same tone in shakti, he laughed and said it wasnt intentional. My brother who is a super mimic then proceeded to talk to amit ji in his own voice..it was hilarious..
I think we imitate those who inspire us, consciously or subconsciously,until we find our own path and direction..but I also hope that we can forgive others and laugh at ourselves from time to time..
Donatella, cool post..the stories are the same, we just add our own flavors to them!
it makes things much more interesting when we do...
will be back later..have fun

Humans are, by natural instinct, very plageristic.

What human being, on this planet, has ever had an "original thought?"

Kavita:

very funny piece.. i love melvin's pieces.. he writes very well!

Here is a very interesting quote:

"Originality is the Art of Concealing your source"
- Anonymous

Thats how you do it!

Cheers,
Desh
Drishtikone.com

I have many.

God does not exist in a NULL universe, but there is something that does.

That is original.

There is that question What is love?

I have seen many answers, but I have never seen the one that came to my mind, and the manner in which I communicate it anywhere else.

It Is what happens when you see your Self in others, it is not something that turns on or of. It happens of it's own accord, Self creation. If what you call love has conditions, it is not Love, or perhaps you have it confused with love of an experience and not Love of the Self.

There is Love of Self, Character, and Experience. The self never changes, but character and experience does.

~Richard Thomas
From the Book “Infinite Play”

Here is another I wrote. There a couple ways to read it One Being a very deep meaning.

Diamonds play with light, that is where brilliance comes from.

Here is another just came to mind. I think it is original.

Love is the gravity between intangible things.

This simply hilarious. Haven't read something so funny in recent times. I wrote a funny piece on this on my blog : http://blog.funnydomainnames.com/2006/06/10/a-plagiarists-tale/.
But it was nearly as good as this one.

Post a comment

Thanks for signing in, . Now you can comment. (sign out)

(If you haven't left a comment here before, you may need to be approved by the site owner before your comment will appear. Until then, it won't appear on the entry. Thanks for waiting.)

Thanks for signing in, . Now you can comment. (sign out)

(If you haven't left a comment here before, you may need to be approved by the site owner before your comment will appear. Until then, it won't appear on the entry. Thanks for waiting.)


Remember me?


Email this entry to:


Your email address:


Message (optional):


Click to check out Intent and Let us know what you think

Recent Posts


HELP

Recent Comments

  • gd007 commented on Spoofing Kaavya

    This simply hilarious. Haven't read something s

  • Richard Thomas commented on Spoofing Kaavya

    Here is another just came to mind. I think it i

  • Richard Thomas commented on Spoofing Kaavya

    There is that question What is love?

    I

  • Richard Thomas commented on Spoofing Kaavya

    I have many.

    God does not exist in a NU

  • Desh kapoor commented on Spoofing Kaavya

    Kavita:

    very funny piece.. i love melvi

Categories