Deepak Chopra - July 23, 2008
An article in the Washington Post On Faith section in response to their question:
The ACLU has asked the U.S. Naval Academy to end prayers at mandatory meals, and yet all branches of the service employ chaplains. What is the proper role of religion in the military?
Speaking realistically, patriotism can't be divorced from religion. Every war is fought with God on our side -- on both sides. And the prevailing notion is always that the enemy is godless. The ACLU may prevail legally, on the basis of separating church and state, but psychology works massively against them. Soldiers know that they may die in battle, and the armed forces must create an ethos that protects their psyches from the impending danger of the conflict. Team spirit and protecting your buddy is one aspect of feeling safe. Trusting your weaponry is another. But so is the idea that God approves of your cause and implicitly will take you to Heaven if the worst befalls.
The entanglement of personal duty, troop morale, patriotism, and religion isn't simple. The ACLU's lawsuit will antagonize anyone on the inside -- besides the "us versus them" mentality about the enemy; there is an "us versus them" attitude toward the civilian public. And rightly so. No one on the home front can understand the searing experience of frontline fighting. Since Vietnam, an additional element has entered the situation: the resentment by soldiers that nobody appreciates their sacrifice. "Vietnam vet" has become synonymous with a new kind of forgotten man -- unsung, alienated, often psychologically scarred for life -- and society seems to feel the same way about Iraqi vets. One sympathizes with their plight; it would be inhuman not to.
That said, it is disturbing to know how deeply fundamentalist Christianity has sunk into the ethos of the armed forces. First noticed with alarm at the Air Force Academy, hard-core proselytizing is apparently rampant. Soldiers pray as they go into training exercises as well as into battle. Atheist and Jewish soldiers are ostracized or hit hard with pressure to convert. The simple notion that fighting for your country is the same as fighting for Jesus is endemic. Yet here, too, the solution isn't clear. Weeding out chaplains who encourage right-wing fundamentalism may do some good, but if cadets and enlistees come from the same Christian background, they have rights, too. Even though one may suppose that young men and women barely in their twenties, if that, are too susceptible to peer pressure and religious indoctrination, we consider them mature enough to go to war. Splitting the difference won't work.
In the end, this feels like a minor point of discord. The Army and Navy are adult institutions, not grade schools, and the admission or exclusion of prayer can be handled by each soldier as he or she sees fit. The armed forces should be left to develop their own ethos. Until we have a draft that puts war on a democratic footing and enlists a broad swath of the population, all of us are outsiders who contribute almost nothing to the Iraq war other than a flurry of words. American militarism is a serious problem that needs radical solutions. Pulling God out of the mess hall is beside the point.
Digg this entry
Add to Del.icio.us
Share on Facebook
Subscribe
Posted by Deepak Chopra at July 23, 2008 04:24 PM
Hello Deepak and Everyone,
What is the proper role of religion in the military? I think the role of religion is the same whether one is in the military or not, in this Nation, meaning, you are to have a choice, a say, in the matter, meaning you have the religious freedom to practice one or not and no one can force it on you either way.
Yes, the armed services have Chaplains, as they should, for all who want, and, need, and, choose to worship a god, their particular god, their way, in their own time and choosing.
I would have no problem with a group of military men and women choosing to sit in an area in the mess hall and pray together, but I would have a problem if they made me sit with them to pray if I didn't want to.
Deepak, are right, I do not think any Nation will ever take God out of war, I mean, who is going to go to war with the DEVIL or SATAN? Surely not a Christian, Muslim, or Jew, so man's war needs God's selling points.
Let's just say that certain "christians" in the military have had a friend in President Bush, his Administration and his wars, a blind eye to spreading the "gospel of Jesus" has been emboldened these last eight years and these certain "warriors of their christian god" have had a ton of power and leeway in strong arming their religious views in a very inappropriate manner.
Yes, the ACLU should step in and act. If the military is abusing their power and forcing and mandating religion in anyway, they should be stopped so that the young men and women who join the military do not have to put up with this kind of abuse of power.
have a great day, in God We Trust:), ruth
I have a friend, who signed on to be a military chaplain just before the Gulf War. Navy/sometimes attached to the Marines/has spent most of his time in combat zones.
Aside from saying a Catholic Mass, most days, his function would seem to be that of a secular social worker(anger management, marriage counseling, money management, parenting advice, relationship mediation between group members who can't seem to get along).
His least favorite task: (when assigned to large, stateside bases) personal hygiene pep talks to recruits who have never gotten the hang of using a tooth brush.
He does give comfort in times of family crisis, or when there is injury and death resulting from combat, but religious and spiritual discussions are few and far between.
It's not the role he was expecting to play when he signed on. But, he enjoys the comraderie and the personal freedom of not being assigned to a parish in Middle America. Also, that officer's paycheck has morphed into quite the retirement nestegg ;)
Religion is used as a psychological tool for behavioral control. Most of religion is a fictional framework riding on top of truth and spirit. Religion has been corrupted by the ego.
"There is a meme war going on, truth vs. fiction and the battle field is the mind."
~Scene from Infinite Play
The next wave of reality infusion is coming with supporting tangible infrastructure.... perhaps in a few hours some will get a glimpse.
Perish that built on fiction.
Beta Intent looks good. I actually have the intentions.me domain not sure what to do with it yet but I am sure it will fit somewhere in the divine framework of things.
In a moment of silence and under my breathe, I said, "Grace".
In remembrance of those who have gone before us, I paused for a few seconds.
If there was food in front of me, you can be sure I was thankful.
If there was plenty to go around, and abundance became a keyword...?
Deepak,
Thanks for food for thought. Makes me wonder how light will get through all the layers of distortion. Maybe one spark at a time? One ray at a time?
Trish~~
...I would be praying ceaselessly
Aloha Deepak and Everyone
It is time for those employed in war, not to show up. Take a holiday. love patty
And that is of course a paid holiday. It is called karma evolution. love patty
People should be allowed to pray to their God, as well as worship their God, which includes the choice not to pray or worship God. Isn't that what freedom is all about and why we became the United States? It was all about FREEDOM and that's why state and religion were separated. The freedom to choose is our right.
Love, Char
I don't like to discuss my recent explorations in the time tunnel of life, but this discussion does make me want to share my recent observations about my learning of past lifetimes.
I have come to relive lifetimes past and in each of these lifetimes I had been a military leader, and my conclusion finally after having learned so much about these particular personalities is that each has had to suffer through a variety of different religious beliefs in each flesh life.
For that reason alone, I will add my two cents worth to this discussion.
First of all, Deepak hit the nail on the head about the importance of a faith in a god of some kind for men who are willing to make the supreme sacrifice.
In order to take another's life, one must have respect even for the loyal opposition or adversary no matter in which civilization the individual may live.
In the case of the present situation, Americans have been taunted by the Muslims that Americans are afraid to die whereas the Muslims are not afraid to die. That is of course a ridiculous taunt, but goading is a natural way to insure that a Muslim can become a martyr if he can somehow or other hoodwink his adversary into fighting him.
So from my long study of the life of military men of the past, many of whom I have lived in a study of past lifetimes, I believe that while religion was very important to each and every one at the time of their ongoing struggles, that the end result is that somehow or other, they all ended up being finalized in me in this stage of life where I have come to know and learn of them. Does that mean that this life is the Heaven for them or the Hell for them? I think of that concept a lot too with regard to a belief in a reborn spiritual life in a new kind of flesh experience.
So for that reason alone, I believe that each military group whether Muslim or Christian should have the right to understand why he has a religious background and how that religious background contributed to his being where he is now, fighting an adversary for whatever reason he is involved in that fight.
In other words, let the men pray, let them believe, and tell the ACLU to worry about other things than whether a man who is willing to lay his life down has the right to say Oh God Help Me Through This Ordeal!
greetings,
God can be the core self, Atman for the Hindus, or the ego, which is simply a reflection of the self, a representation. People worship both. The spirit dwells in the mind, as the core self, but is masked by the ego, which falsely claims to be spirit (http://www.psychocience.com). So we find all kinds of things being done by "religious" people.
Thanks for signing in, . Now you can comment. (sign out)
(If you haven't left a comment here before, you may need to be approved by the site owner before your comment will appear. Until then, it won't appear on the entry. Thanks for waiting.)Thanks for signing in, . Now you can comment. (sign out)
(If you haven't left a comment here before, you may need to be approved by the site owner before your comment will appear. Until then, it won't appear on the entry. Thanks for waiting.)greetings,
God can be the core self, Atma
I don't like to discuss my recent explorations
People should be allowed to pray to their God,
And that is of course a paid holiday. It is cal
Aloha Deepak and Everyone
It is time fo
A truly eye-opening book that explores just how massively war-making is embedded in American life was released just his year: Turse, Nick. "The Complex: How the Military Invades Our Everyday Lives." New York: Metropolitan Books, 2008.
Tis a very, if not quite sad, read. Here is a quote:
"In the coming years, we're apt to see more previously foreign-deployed aspects of the Complex—such as the use of mercenaries, surveillance drones, and computer-aided tracking technology—appear in the United States courtesy of the homeland-security complex. Meanwhile, fueled by wars and occupations abroad, the Complex will also continue to swell. As this book has tried to demonstrate, it is already an entity light-years beyond the size, scale, and scope of Dwight Eisenhower’s military-industrial complex, and its most powerful aspects don’t have the look of a garrison state at all. From sunglasses to video games, golf courses to doughnuts, hot movies to hot cars, much of the way the Complex manifests itself hardly looks “military” at all.
For most Americans, and many other peoples across the planet, the Complex is a powerful engine that helps to drive our world, a vast system of systems, a real Matrix, hidden in plain sight. The Complex thrives on the very obliviousness of the civilian population to its existence in the world it has made so much its own. But if you look closely, it can suddenly come into focus and be seen almost everywhere: on our TVs and in the movies we watch; in the video games we play and the products we buy; in the coffee we drink and the boots we wear; in the stocks we own and the Web sites we visit; and in almost every other facet of our lives” (271).
pax vobiscum