intentBlog intent is the emerging asian consciousness giving birth to a global mind shift

IMF's Rising Quantum of Nation State Failures: Domino Effects and Unintended Consequences

DK Matai - October 27, 2008

Dear Friends, what do Iceland, Ukraine, Hungary, Belarus and Pakistan have in common? These countries are on the brink of financial collapse and the International Monetary Fund (IMF) is in the process of bailing them out as the lender of last resort to cash-strapped countries.

The Washington-based institution is one of the cornerstones of the Bretton Woods system that has governed global finance since World War II. At the end of August 2008, the IMF had USD 341 billion available from the combined quota payments of its member countries to offer partially as loans to countries facing financial difficulties. According to distinguished ATCA members, this may not be enough and the IMF may not be able to solve the massive motorway pile-up of nation-state-failures as more than 35 nations end up in the queue over the coming year. Based on ATCA estimates, even ten times the IMF reserves, ie, USD 3 to 4 trillion may also not be enough worldwide to provide emergency financial relief over the coming few years, given the ATCA analyses "The Invisible One Quadrillion Dollar Equation," "Why are Markets still falling? The Tsunami caused by Derivatives and Deleveraging", and "Bretton Woods II -- The New Global Economic Architecture for the 21st Century."

Interlinked Domino Effects

The rising quantum of nation state failures as The Great Unwind accelerates, has to be seen in the light of the large-scale domino effects across the world and their unintended consequences. In a nutshell, this means that failures in one place, one sector or one asset class can trigger avalanches on multiple-sides of the globe. When all asset classes head south simultaneously, this can cause the national economies of many countries to rupture simultaneously raising the possibility of domestic turmoil and trans-national geo-political black swans. In particular, there is a heightened concern about emerging-market economies. The value of most emerging-market currencies dropped between 10% and 20% against the dollar over the course of the last few weeks as the world's hedge funds -- three-quarters of which are dollar-based -- and other investment funds bailed out of their foreign investments and repatriated their money. Those investors seem terrified by the aggressive action taken by several

emerging-market central banks to shore up their currencies. Capital flows to emerging markets have been colossal in the last few years, leading to booming property and export markets. But many of these economies have limited capital reserves and excessively high debt-to-GDP ratios. As Western investors bring their money home, many emerging-markets' central banks are limited in what they can do to shore up their economies, so they have no choice other than to turn to the IMF.

The IMF has just announced a USD 16.5 bn loan for Ukraine and a "substantial" package for Hungary. This followed a USD 2.1 bn loan to Iceland and came amid appeals for assistance from other countries, including Belarus and Pakistan. The loans would be spread over two years. Let us examine the case of Ukraine and Hungary in more detail:

Ukraine's IMF loan is 800 times the size of its "quota," or the amount of money the country pays to be a member of the IMF. The IMF funds itself primarily through these quotas, which are assigned to each country upon entry based on the size of its economy. Ukraine's loan is small in comparison to the country's external debt, which is estimated at USD 55 billion due this year. Ukraine stopped early withdrawals from savings accounts this month in a bid to halt a run on banks. The central bank has bailed out several banks and the Ukrainian stock market has lost more than 70% of its value this year. The vast former Soviet Union country is getting much less money from its main export, steel, because of a slump in global demand for commodities, and is using up foreign currency reserves to support its currency, the Hryvnia. Its currency has slumped by a fifth to a record low and its property boom -- particularly in the capital, Kiev -- has turned into a bubble on the verge of bursting. One additional problem for Ukraine is that its balance of payments is heavily influenced by the price Russia sets for the country's vital imports of natural gas. These factors could lead to problems for the government to pay back some of the foreign loans that have helped boost Ukraine's economy in recent years as well as to make up for budget deficits. Furthermore, a feud between President Viktor Yushchenko and Prime Minister Yulia Tymoshenko over the president's decision to call fresh elections risks exacerbating the country's deep economic problems. Ukraine is facing its third parliamentary election in three years! Yet the country has promised the IMF that it will set a balanced budget and reform its banking sector in exchange for the loan. Ratings agency Standard & Poor's cut its currency rating on Ukraine late Friday even though it believed an IMF loan would be offered, saying a lack of internal political agreement could mean the country wouldn't be able to implement the IMF's program to fix the economy. With political uncertainty Ukraine may have to go under the IMF's total economic stewardship. On the other hand, Hungary's vulnerability is primarily due to a large current account and budget deficit, a partially overvalued currency, a low stock of foreign reserve and a high level of short-term foreign currency debt. Facing a sharp fall in the national currency, the Forint, the country's central bank decided last week to raise its key interest rate by three points to 11.5%.

According to distinguished ATCA members based at the Bretton Woods institutions, the IMF money being provided to nation states on the brink of failure, is only half of the issue, conditionality is the key. Alongside the significant restoration packages, the IMF has to maintain its push for more serious economic reform, flexible exchange rates, far-reaching reforms in the banking sector and more privatisation to ensure that the shaky nation states find a step-by-step way to come out of the financial quagmire without becoming another unintended consequence in a long series of unfortunate yet interlinked domino effects.

[ENDS]

We welcome your thoughts, observations and views. Thank you.

With love and warm wishes to you and family


DK with family

DK Matai

The Philanthropia, mi2g.net

DK's online community participation includes:

Open ATCA, IntentBlog, Holistic Quantum Relativity Group, LinkedIn, Facebook, Ecademy, Xing, Spock, A&B Blog and QDOS. [Profile in pdf]

Holistic Quantum Relativity Group

A new Holistic Quantum Relativity Group is being set up here.

e8plane2a.jpg

Holistic (H) E8 Vector Visualisation in String Theory (Q+R) like the 1,000 Petal Sahasrara Lotus in Spirituality

Email:
Visit the HQR Group

Add to Technorati Favorites

Add to Technorati Favorites

Add to Technorati Favorites

DK Matai's Facebook profile

Digg this entryDigg this entry  Add to Del.icio.usAdd to Del.icio.us  Share on FacebookShare on Facebook  Subscribe to this AuthorSubscribe

Posted by DK Matai at October 27, 2008 03:34 AM

Comments

DK, do you want to elaborate on this:

'In the midst of all this, here is the Quadrillion dollar ATCA question, "Is Switzerland still the place to park Rolls-Royce capital in the middle of a global meltdown?" Watch the Swiss Franc'.

Dear DK,

Despite that I have totally other things on my mind at the moment, there was an article in one of our Dutch newspapers that caught my attention with regard to your essay here above.

It was about IMF and the title: IMF will soon have shortage of money. Because of what you already have written.

Conclusion of the article was that none of IMF’s measures will bring relief if the economical Super Powers – or rather the countries that have enough dollars to spare – do not cooperate. Those countries will have to agree to help a number of other countries who have encountered problems in the aftermath of this crisis.

Well, after the meeting of Asian and European government leaders last weekend, China wants to actively participate in the top meeting in Washington about a Bretton Woods II.

And no doubt India will too.

Sarkozy has already mentioned he wanted both China and India to be present in Washington.

Well, if Obama will be elected, he will be the third factor that is needed here I suppose.

Lol, all good things will come in three again.

I admit that here my wish is the ‘father’ or perhaps better ‘mother’ of my thoughts :)


Love, Mieke

The International Monetary Fund
Sizes Up
Huge Slate of Financial Rescues

D. K. Matai
Asymmetric Threats Contingency Alliance
October 27, 2008


We wish to acknowledge the extremely valuable input
of various Asymmetric Threats Contingency Alliance colleagues
in Bretton Woods institutions and the International Monetary Fund.

#######


Iceland, Ukraine, Hungary, Belarus, and Pakistan are on the brink of financial collapse, and as the lender of last resort to cash-strapped countries, the International Monetary Fund (IMF) is in the process of bailing them out. The Washington-based institution is one of the cornerstones of the Bretton Woods system, which has governed global finance since World War II. At the end of August 2008, the combined quota payments of the IMF member countries amounted to US $ .341 trillion, some of which was available as loans to countries facing financial difficulties. This impressive available loan stock may not be enough, however, and the IMF may not be able to solve the massive motorway pile-up of nation-state failures as more than thirty-five nations end up in the queue during the coming year. Even ten times the IMF reserves—that is, US $ 3 trillion to 4 trillion—also may not be enough worldwide to provide emergency financial relief during the coming few years.*

Unexpected Chain Reactions

The rising quantum of nation-state financial failures stems in part from certain large-scale, self-potentiating, and often unpredictable domino effects of the Great Unwind crisis as it spreads across the world. Failures in one nation, one sector, one aspect, or one asset class can trigger unforeseeable avalanches on multiple sides of the globe—for instance, as in the recent experience with the world’s emerging-market economies.

Capital flows to the emerging-market economies have been colossal in the last few years, leading to booming markets in property and exports. But many of these economies have small capital reserves and excessively high debt-to-GDP ratios, and in recent weeks the value of most emerging-market currencies dropped between 10 percent and 20 percent against the dollar, leading these countries to take aggressive actions to shore up their currencies. These aggressive actions struck panic into the hearts of many investors, and as a result, the world's hedge funds (three-fourths of which are dollar based) and other investment funds suddenly and nearly en masse totally bailed out of their foreign investments there and repatriated their money. As Western investors bring their money home, many emerging markets' central banks are suddenly much more limited in what they can do to shore up their economies, so they have no choice but to turn to the IMF.

Ukraine and Hungary

The IMF has just announced a US $ 16.5 billion loan for Ukraine and a "substantial" package for Hungary. This followed a US $ 2.1 billion loan to Iceland and came amid appeals for assistance from other countries, including Belarus and Pakistan. The loans would be spread over two years. As a condition for receiving the significant restoration monies being provided by the IMF to nation-states on the brink of financial failure, the recipient nations must institute, under IMF guidelines, certain economic reforms (such as, perhaps, exchange rate flexibilization, far-reaching reforms in the banking sector, and more privatization) in order to extricate themselves from the financial quagmire and to avoid becoming further entrenched in a long series of far-reaching domino effects of nation-state financial failures.

Ukraine's IMF loan is 800 times the size of its "quota," or the amount of money the country pays to be a member of the IMF. (The IMF funds itself primarily through these quotas, which are assigned to each joining country based on the size of its economy.) Ukraine's loan is small in comparison to the country's external debt, which is estimated at US $ 55 billion due this year. Ukraine stopped early withdrawals from savings accounts this month in a bid to halt a run on banks. The central bank has bailed out several banks, and the Ukrainian stock market has lost more than 70 percent of its value this year. The vast former Soviet Union country is getting much less money from its main export, steel, because of a slump in global demand for commodities and is using up foreign-currency reserves to support its currency, the hryvnia. The hryvnia has slumped by one-fifth to a record low, and the Ukrainian property boom—particularly in the capital, Kiev—has turned into a bubble on the verge of bursting. One additional problem for Ukraine is that its balance of payments is heavily influenced by the price Russia sets for Ukraine's vital imports of natural gas. These factors could lead to problems for the government in meeting budget shortfalls and in paying back some of the foreign loans that have helped boost Ukraine's economy in recent years. Furthermore, a feud between President Viktor Yushchenko and Prime Minister Yulia Tymoshenko over the president's decision to call fresh elections threatens to exacerbate the country's deep economic problems. Ukraine is facing its third parliamentary election in three years! Yet the country has promised the IMF that it will set a balanced budget and reform its banking sector in exchange for the loan. Ratings agency Standard & Poor's lowered its currency rating on Ukraine a few days ago even though it believed an IMF loan would be offered, saying a lack of internal political agreement could mean the country would not be able to implement the IMF's program to fix the economy. Given this political uncertainty, Ukraine may have to go under the IMF's total economic stewardship.

Hungary's vulnerability, in contrast, stems primarily from large budgetary and current-account deficits, a low stock of foreign reserves, a large short-term foreign-currency debt, and a somewhat overvalued currency. Facing a sharp fall in the national currency, the country's central bank decided last week to raise its key interest rate by 3 points to 11.5 percent.


------------

* Please see the following three related Asymmetric Threats Contingency Alliance analyses at http://www.mi2g.net :


1. "The Invisible One Quadrillion Dollar Equation"

2. "Why Are Markets Still Falling? The Tsunami Caused by Derivatives and Deleveraging"

3. "Bretton Woods II—The New Global Economic Architecture for the 21st Century"


---------------------------

OMG!! I magled ANOTHER one

i really have to DO something about the manic phase of my manic-depression

seems I LIKE an article, i have to FIDDLE with it, as a way of experiencing it more fully

hmmmmmmmm

maybe articles are replacing Men, in my old age


anyway, thanks for these very informational and thought-provoking articles and also apologies to our resident source of WONDERFUL and INSPIRING ideas and delicious, helpful perspective -- namely, D. K. Matai

I believe the precious man must have the patience and forbearance of an Angel..... :)

Post a comment

Thanks for signing in, . Now you can comment. (sign out)

(If you haven't left a comment here before, you may need to be approved by the site owner before your comment will appear. Until then, it won't appear on the entry. Thanks for waiting.)

Thanks for signing in, . Now you can comment. (sign out)

(If you haven't left a comment here before, you may need to be approved by the site owner before your comment will appear. Until then, it won't appear on the entry. Thanks for waiting.)


Remember me?


Email this entry to:


Your email address:


Message (optional):