intentBlog intent is the emerging asian consciousness giving birth to a global mind shift

Transparency and Tradeoffs: The Missing T's in The Healthcare Industry

Rayman Mathoda - December 23, 2008

AV’s recent inpatient surgery experience - she had a cervical dystectomy (relatively common neck surgery) - reminded of how fundamentally flawed our US healthcare system is. Almost every industry/market that’s “efficient” functions on some basic common principles/dynamics: Customers make purchasing decisions based on cost, quality and service and producers/companies compete on the basis of these 3 core product/service “differentiation” dimensions.

Let’s take the retail industry as an example. Walmart is all about being low cost and has build a business model that continuously wrings cost out of the entire supply chain for the goods they sell. A store like Nordstrom on the other hand tries to be more upscale, so it competes on service and to a lesser extent quality (by carrying brands perceived to be higher quality). And Louis Vitton, Tiffany, and other luxury brands compete largely on quality only (with quality being defined as a combination of style/perception, brand value, material, cut, etc.).

The key to the above tradeoffs occuring, of course, is information (transparency) about the 3 differentiating dimensions, particularly quality and cost….to enable consumers to evaluate different companies and make their decision based on what matters most to them. But none of this is possible in healthcare - an industry that is almost a fifth of US GDP!

In healthcare, you make a decision with no idea of what it will cost you and really no way/system of getting such a cost estimate without significant effort. And quality is an entirely different matter. Where cost is difficult but not impossible to assess, quality is. There is absolutely no data available to consumers to help them understand the experience level and output/performance (aka “outcomes” in healthcare) of the doctor they choose to go with. And did I mention there’s no systematic way of finding a doctor that meets your needs? The whole system of finding a doctor is primitive - you ask around to see if anyone you know (including other doctors one might know) have a recommendation (which is again, largely based on perception/reputation and not facts).

I am definitely a believer that government led investment in infrastucture is a key tool to help get the US out of the current economic crisis (while making sensible investments which will pay off and are required for our long term health). I would love to see the Obama administration address some of the issues above to help get the US healthcare industry more nimble, competitive and no doubt efficient.

Digg this entryDigg this entry  Add to Del.icio.usAdd to Del.icio.us  Share on FacebookShare on Facebook  Subscribe to this AuthorSubscribe

Posted by Rayman Mathoda at December 23, 2008 02:31 PM

Comments

Merry Christmas, Ramana!

What a coincidence. Who is AV?

I, myself, just got home yesterday from the hospital.

An anterior cervical discectomy and fusion was precisely

the name of the procedure that I underwent. (Good! That is a word.)

Underwent or "to undergo" means unconsciously, I suppose.

Thank God for mind-zapping, brain-numbing anesthesiologists!

So how much of the total bill will I have to pay? I have BC/BS as my insurer.

I do know that using preferred providers knocks the bill down by usually 30-40%.

Poor, poor people who have no insurance have to foot the whole shebang.

How really, really stupid it is to assume that folks with few resources

can afford to pay more than the rest of us who do have a carrier.

It is completely senseless to me. This seems to be

one of the selective services that is also a medical necessity.

I could have continued to put up with this pain

in the neck for the rest of my life, but I choose not to.

It was not a life-threatening situation then, and now I must figure

that a lot of people do do without, so it's no wonder that Grinches live on.

They are fashionably green, too, like me in the spring of my life.

My surgeon is a pro, and I have a right to believe that he was the perfect choice for me.

For this I can be grateful, and I do feel fortunate even when it hurts.

Mending every second is possible, and that in itself is miraculous.

Although I do lookk forward to drinking a reall y good beer asap!

Take care now! Uncle Tree

Post a comment

Thanks for signing in, . Now you can comment. (sign out)

(If you haven't left a comment here before, you may need to be approved by the site owner before your comment will appear. Until then, it won't appear on the entry. Thanks for waiting.)

Thanks for signing in, . Now you can comment. (sign out)

(If you haven't left a comment here before, you may need to be approved by the site owner before your comment will appear. Until then, it won't appear on the entry. Thanks for waiting.)


Remember me?


Email this entry to:


Your email address:


Message (optional):